Skip navigation

Below is an excerpt from a letter my patient, KP received from The Trustees of the Plumbers’ Welfare Fund in September 2010:

Elimination of Mental Health Benefits

Effective October 1, 2010, no amount is payable under the Welfare Plan for claims connected with the treatment of a Mental Health Condition. A Mental Health Condition is generally defined as a condition or illness that affects an individual’s emotional or psychological well-being. Mental Health Conditions include, but are not limited to, dementia, delirium, anxiety disorder, schizophrenia, depression, bipolar disorder, delusions, obsessive-compulsive behavior, Anorexia, Bulimia, attention deficit disorder, mental retardation and autism.”

Below is KP’s Résumé:

  • Current Position: (held for the past 18 months): Field Superintendent/ Project Manager with a 35 man Plumbing Company. He began as an entry-level plumber and within 3 months was promoted to his current position; second in command only to the company’s owner. A company with $3M annual revenues at the time of his promotion it has since grown to revenues of $15M the year following KP’s promotion. Every member of the company, including its owner, would attribute this explosive growth in the face of a down economy to KP’s performance as their Superintendent. They would tell you about his innate leadership abilities, his ability to command respect while being perceived as a genuinely nice guy who cares about the people he works with. This quality, combined with the treasure-trove of plumbing wisdom KP absorbed in his quarter century in the field, has made this explosion in his company’s growth seem effortless. Not being one for accolades, I do know that KP takes pride in the fact that he is the first one there in the morning and the last to leave; this is just who he is and this is just the way he does things.
  • October 2006 to Present: With his sheer willpower and the support of his family and his physician (yours truly), KP became a Recovering Cocaine Addict.
  • October 2006KP in another failed suicide attempt took an overdose of medicine which I prescribed to treat his Mood Disorder.
  • From 1967 to October 2006: KP, like 25% of the American population, was functionally impaired due to  a Mental Health Disorder and, as is the case for two-thirds of the members of this population, KP went unrecognized and untreated in spite of his frequent use of the healthcare system. (1)
  • Career PathAs are nearly 10% of persons in this country, KP was born with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). (2) By the age of 14, KP went on to acquire Bipolar Disorder when he effortlessly met the stringent requirements for achieving his first full-blown Major Depressive Episode.  It was at about this time PK began dabbling in something in which he fortunately never became very proficient; suicide. A novice in the skill of snorting cocaine at 17, he rapidly ascended to become a full fledged functional Cocaine Addict by the age of 21. No surprise really, since most 17 year olds with PK’s diagnoses that do not receive treatment become substance abusers and addicts by the time they turn 21, with cocaine being the usual drug of choice. (3) Until 2005, KP continued to self medicate with an addictive, deadly and illegal substance in his futile attempt to treat the agonizing symptoms of mental illness. Miraculously, due to his strong faith, his will to live and his having family and friends that loved and believed in him, he is now the 12 Million Dollar Man; twice as good as any TV superhero.

While KP is, indeed, a rare person his diagnoses are all too common. He came to me in 2005 to find out why he was experiencing severe pain from a relatively minor back injury, he had gained about 60 pounds and was having digestive problems. Had I not done 2 minutes worth of screenings for Depression, Bipolar Disorder and ADHD, as I do on every new patient to my practice, these symptoms never would have come out from KP’s spontaneously elicited complaints. (4) (5) (6) Fortunately, when I reviewed the Mental Health Screeners with KP he was open, honest and quite frankly, relived to share with me the details of the symptoms from which he suffered  silently for the previous quarter century; and his silence was not due to his fear of being stigmatized. KP, as intelligent a person as he is, simply never even considered that these symptoms were relevant to any physician.  You can imagine his surprise when I told him that he was suffering from a medical condition as treatable as Congestive Heart Failure but, more common and with a far better prognosis. He trusted me enough to commit to taking 4 medications per day for the rest of his life.

I am recounting the case of KP the Plumber, not to show my readers what a great physician I am. What I accomplished with KP does not require the skills of a great physician, just a good one. The treatment of mental illness is as straight forward as the treatment of Asthma, Hypertension or any other common disorder physicians treat on a daily basis. Yet, two-thirds of persons suffering with mental illness are simply not recognized; and this is not due to their not accessing the healthcare system. (7) Persons with undiagnosed mental illness use the healthcare system more than those persons without mental illness. (7)They most commonly do so for the evaluation of the physical symptoms that are actually a common component of mental illness. (7) Recognizing mental illness is as simple as asking every patient if they have it or not; this is simply not being done and until it is there will continue to be needless human suffering and an excessive waste of healthcare dollars.

In the 18 months during which KP increased his company’s annual revenues by $12M, the total expenditure on his health care, including my treatment and his medications, was a grand total of $13,500.  Stated another way, for every $1 invested in KP’s mental health his company realized a return of nearly $900. Any venture capitalist would gladly have purchased as many shares as possible of KP Inc. Unfortunately for KP he is not a publicly traded company on the NASDAQ and unfortunately for The Trustees of the Plumbers’ Union Welfare Fund they only consider cost and not return on investment when they make healthcare decisions. This gives me cause to seriously question their sanity.


Mitchell R. Weisberg, MD. MP


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: